A personal view of Knowlton, Quebec, the Eastern Townships most beautiful village.

BromeLakeBlog Forced to Remove Unauthorized Content
Read the full story here.

You can't walk stroll into Flannigans and steal a bag of Bagels. You can't walk in the front door of Bousada and walk out the back door with a sofa you haven't paid for. And now one local blogger has learned that you can't just take someone elses creative property just because you know how to cut and paste.

Luckily the laws of the land, laws that brave Canadians have fought for over several great Wars, have evolved to protect us in the age of computers and while stealing content, pictures, words, stories and ideas from websites might be as easy as a Control-C that doesn't make it right. It is, actually, against the law just as any theft of intellectual property or material goods is.

Now the BromeLakeBlog has learned that posting content from another website without permission is pretty much considered theft and their web hosting company has had the offending material stripped from their servers in accordance with the laws. Bravo!

Just because we're a small little town doesn't make this the wild west! Laws are laws and no-one can walk into your house and walk off with the TV set can they...but maybe some people think that if those bagels at Flannigans are a little stale then putting them in their pocket and walking out without paying is ok?

Trademarks and copyrights exist to prevent ideas from being stolen, now, BromeLakeBlog.com has come face to face with the reality of blogging on the internet by having material from their blog removed by their hosting company because of the DMCA legal notice of copyright infringement filed by us.

BLB has been PWNEDYep, the judge has rendered a fair and sound judgement and BLB has been PWNED! This is all thanks to the digital laws that protect the Internet. DMCA stands for Digital Millennium Copyright Act and basically what it does is allow content creators an efficient means of ensuring that their original content is not used re-produced or diseminated without permission.

In this case BromeLakeBlog.com posted a 697 word article that had been written for and by DestinationKnowlton.com without consent. When our website asked for the article to be removed we were told that it wouldn't be removed. It wasn't until we went through the effort of filing legal papers with the web host that article was removed from their blog. Incredible that in a such a small town their could be such disrespect...and right in public for all to see! We felt as if it was like having to call the police on the neighbour who "borrowed" the lawn mower and then refuses to give it back!

The offending web site literally laughed in our face at our requests for a return of the stolen goods! The nerve! The laughing quickly turned to indignation as the hosting company followed up on the DMCA investigation we initiated and forced the removal of our content. The blog owner, Morris Croghan, called us communists comparing us to China and acting bewildered that we could claim copyright because of a minor speeling mistake! Denial...not a river in Egypt folks!!

Another victory for intellectual property owners! Just like any sort of property theft, online theft of content is illegal, but some people seem to think that just because it's on the Internet you can just take it. Thankfully the DMCA has proven a useful law to protect us from robbery by these sorts of people who would steal the bread off our family's plates!

Brome Lake Blog? Your delivery of fail has arrived!"It wasn't the fact that they borrowed our article" said "Darling Dave", head creative writer at Destination Knowlton, "It was the fact that they weaseled around our polite requests at removal! They didn't leave a proper attribution and instead of using a summary and a link back to our article which may have rendered their usage "fair use" they chose a juvenile rebuttle of name-calling colored with ignorance and a self-righteous mocking of the rules. Rules that keep our society from entering chaos!"

"We've had our pictures and some of our articles re-printed, summarized and used in print and online as well as done interviews with CBC discussing items that have appeared on our blog. To have it stolen by a local noob blogger who has done nothing but smear our website along with other townsfolk really hurt, we're a small community and to see such viceral disregard and personal attacks is troubling. Property theft was the last straw. But now, seeing we've won our claim against this activity, we feel redeemed!"

Luckily for creative people in the townships, you are protected from digital thieves, you just need to stand up for your rights! Use the DMCA if you need to. Good always triumphs over evil, well, according to Batman at least!

But now...as the legal dust settles...let's hope now that thsee two parties who have agreed to disagree will continue to work on their blogs, serving their different audiences as best they can, with at least a spoonfull of respect and and not have things turn into something that the entire Eastern Townships is ashamed of...let's face it: isn't the future of our town, our province and our country bigger than any blog or the ego of any one person?


Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree with you fully... I've seen the blog... as far as I can see there are multiple cases of public slander... as far as I know you should, and all those who have been victimized, have legal avenues to follow for condemnation and compensation for this.

I don't believe you can speak publicly about individuals in that matter unless they are already "public" figures, and even at that, information has to be respectful and true. Openly degrading someone has grounds for criminal charges... I could be wrong, but should be worth a look.

I'd say there are at least a dozen people who could make a claim against the blog. Also keep in mind that the moderator doesn't moderate at all... he is the most active commentator so it really doesn't even fit the model of a blog. It is simply an open and public attack against private citizens...

Saturday, March 06, 2010 1:05:00 AM  

Post a Comment

Please leave a comment for DestinationKnowlton.com.

<< Home

Duck Festival - Canard en Fete | Good Samaritan Rescues Dog From Attack | Maybe Drivers Should Go Back To School | Technically Teknika is Taking Too Long | Three Knowlton Businesses Reach Finals | Finally! I Can Hear You Now! | Three Knowlton Businesses Reach Finals | Brome Lake Duck Festival - Canard En Fete | Going Green: A Story With Two Sides | Ecosphere: The Environmental Fair Comes | Brome Lake Classic Golf Tournament | The Big Brome Fair: Aug 31 - Sept 3 | Arts Sutton Casino Night | Quebec Lakes Closed For No Good Reason | Getting Ready for the Big Brome Fair | Celebrating the Big Brome Fair | Quebec Lakes Closed For No Good Reason | Twin Vernissage at the Knowlton Gallery | Welcome to Knowlton, Quebec | Sutton, Quebec Art Gallery Events | The Leaning Tree Says Good-Bye | Knowlton Marina Is The Place To Beat the Heat | Lac Brome Rentals Signal Growth | Brome Lake Duck Festival | Is Teknika Missing The Boat | Resident Sabotages Town with Vandalism | Knowlton Celebrates Canada's Birthday | Knowlton Runner Wins Tour Du Lac | Town Reveals New Logo | Denis Farley Show In Sutton | Apple Blossom Time | Knowlton Public Market Is Back | Dog Show Parade Has Tails Wagging | Brome Lake Announces Lake Plan | Teknika Report Delayed Again | Renaissance Lac Brome Annual Meeting | Knowlton Imposes Strict Dress Code | Brome-Missisquoi Election Results | Spring Break Party On Brome Lake | Liberals Sliding Down The "Poles" | Tobogganing & Valentines Provide Warmth | Centre Lac Brome Lake Center Open | Mont Morin Likely No Threat To Ski Bromont | Renaissance Lac Brome Continue Raising Funds | Emballages Knowlton Merges With US Firm | Lost Cat Found In Knowlton | Brome Taxes Go Through The Roof | Action Plan or Fantasy Land? | Anna Nixon At Sutton Gallery | Happy New Year 2007 | Did Someone Say Winter? | Spectacular Migration of Birds | Knowlton en Lumiere: A bright idea! | Remembrance Day in Knowlton | Charge of the Light Brigade | Halloween in Knowlton | Floating Islands put Knowlton in Spotlight | Gerald Swann: featured painter | Renaissance Lac Brome Meeting | What Can We Do With Lac Brome? | A Perfect Thanksgiving Weekend | Sutton Fundraiser A Magical Evening | Environmental Fair Comes to Brome | Weather won't "Fowl" Duck Fest Week-end | Dawson Tragedy Impacts Knowlton Children | The Amazing Race...Knowlton Style! | Back to School: Watch Out For Our Kids! | Can You Hear Me Now? Cell Tower To Be Built | Brome Lake Ducks Maintain Rugby Record | Eastern Townships Challenge visits Knowlton | Knowlton Landmark Hotel Wins Award | "Raccoon Cookies" Fight Rabies Outbreak | Dangerous Cyanobacteria Closes Brome Lake | Quaint Village or Monster Truck Show? | Taking Aim At The Mayor | New Cobblestone Crosswalks | Knowlton Residents Upset With State of Mill Pond | Canada Day In Knowlton | RCMP Musical Ride Thrills Townshippers | Running the Tour Du Lac Brome | Public Market Opens In Knowlton | New IGA for Knowlton | David Suzuki Visits Knowlton | Rain Swells Cold Brook | Fessenden: Knowlton's Unsung Hero | Shawn Phillips Visits Knowlton | The Sounds Of Spring in Knowlton | Fire Department To Get New Fire Trucks | Speed Limits Don't Match Road Reality | New Benches Installed Beside Pettes Library | Uniprix Ready For Expansion...Next Up: Tim Horton! | Knowlton Business Faces Fine for Illegal Sign | Knowlton Gas Station Says Buh-Bye! | SPCA Adoptions Raise the "Woof" | Changing the Victorian Landscape of Knowlton | Celebrating a Hollywood Hero from Knowlton | No High-Speed Internet Upsets Knowlton | Bilingual Means "Anything But English" in Brome? | Welcome to Knowlton, Knowlton | Police Plan More Patrols For Knowlton | Knowlton Sculptor Immortalizes Hockey | Don Davison Book Launch In Knowlton | CBC's Bill Richardson in Knowlton | Painters of the Eastern Townships | Quoi de Neuf - What's New in Knowlton! | Meet The Candidates - Election | Brome Duck Festival Gets Quackin' | The Beatles Coming to Knowton | Tour Des Arts Celebrates | Property For Sale In Knowlton | World Class Concerts Coming To Knowlton | June Garden Event Shows Townships Beauty | Tunde Odunlade in Knowlton | Knowlton Going To The Dogs...Again! | Garage Sale Bylaw Rains On Yard Sales | So Our Trees Are Becoming A Nuisance? | Country Chic Fashion Show | June Garden Event Shows Townships Beauty | World Class Concerts Coming To Knowlton | Knowlton Tree rivals Rockefeller Plaza | Lac Brome Rentals Signal Growth | Knowlton en Lumiere: A bright idea! | Remembrance Day in Knowlton | Charge of the Light Brigade | Halloween in Knowlton | Floating Islands put Knowlton in Spotlight | Gerald Swann: featured painter | Brome Fair Feedback is Not All Good | Brome Lake to be Sold For Biofuel | Chickasaw and The Raid From Hell | Cyclist Doping Scandal Harms Locals | Good Samaritan Saves Man From Dog Attack | Who Turned Out The Lights | SAQré bleu! Knowlton gets a new liquor store! | Paul Martin Trades Trees For Tees | A Time to Reflect on Life | Winter Storm Hits Eastern Townships We have the worst drivers | New Cellphone Tower in Knowlton Apple Blossom Time | Citizens Angry at Lack of Bilingual Signs | Festival of Lights | Brome Taxes Through The Roof